Showing posts with label What If. Show all posts
Showing posts with label What If. Show all posts

Thursday, August 15, 2019

What If There Were Two Versions Of Batman

Dealing with the death of Batman.  Seems odd but true, hinted at in this issue of Detective Comics, but not something come about in the normal way.

Spoiling the secret hinted at on the cover....so, read on only if you dare!


The Strange Death Of Batman

In the main part of the story of Detective Comics #347 (January, 1966) by Gardner Fox, Carmine Infantino and Joe Giella, the Dynamic Duo faced off against a new foe, the Bouncer.  The Bouncer was a criminal metallurgist, who created a suit out of a special combination including metal and plastics that he called Elastalloy, which allowed him to rebound off of any material.

The Bouncer was able to best Batman and Robin multiple times, before Batman had figured out a way to beat him, using science to stress the material of the villain's costume (and gun), which prevented them from bouncing, allowing Batman to be victorious against this baffling bad guy.


What If

Here's where readers are suddenly introduced to Gardner Fox, the man who had penned this very tale!


The writer of the tale takes you through his thought process for the issue, but then takes the reader along a different path...one where Batman's plan was not successful, with the Bouncer killing Batman with his gun. 

Robin mourns his mentor, with the Justice League promising the lad that they will bring in the villain, but Robin does it on his own anyway, instead of finding the elastic limit of Elastalloy, he gives it elastic fatigue.  Robin defeats the villain, but is still alone....until he hears the voice of Bruce Wayne! 

 
It is the Silver Age introduction Batman of Earth-2, who, since his Robin had grown up, came to Earth-1 to now be a mentor to young Robin, bringing along the Earth-2 Alfred as well (Alfred had been thought to be dead at this time).

Now, this was still early in the history of the multiple Earths, taking place between the 3rd and 4th JLA/JSA team-ups, and certainly before readers had been introduced to the grown up Earth-2 Robin...

....but, a real interesting little tale allowing Gardner Fox to quietly sneak a little of the DC Universe into Batman's Detective Comics.

Thursday, January 19, 2017

Captain America as President?

Captain America as President?  That was the basis of the story of What If? #26 (April, 1981), with Captain America running for and successfully becoming the President of the United States in a story by Mike W. Barr, with Roger McKenzie, Don Perlin, Roger Stern and John Byrne all contributing, and art by Herb Trimpe and Mike Esposito....all under a cover by Marie Severin (with Captain America co-creator Jack Kirby swearing in Steve Rogers, with Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan in attendance). 
 
Of course, if Captain America takes over the United States, wouldn't that force the Red Skull to get his own country?

The issue also contained a story about an alternate reality Man-Thing, and some history on the Eternals and the Kree (the last two alien races that Jack Kirby had a hand in creating....).


This story was an alternate world version of the Captain America story from Captain America #250 (October, 1980, by Roger Stern, John Byrne and Joe Rubenstein, with plot ideas by Don Perlin and Roger McKenzie), wherein Captain America was approached about running for President as the people's choice.  Cap decided for the good of the country, that his being president would not be good for America.....which the What If? story played out. 


How can you judge a President? 


How about by what he does while he is President?

Monday, July 20, 2015

Blue Area of the Moon

On July 20, 1969, astronaut Neil Armstrong uttered the immortal worlds...


"That's one small step for [a] man, and one giant leap for mankind".


(This scene, from Stan Lee and Jack Kirby's Fantastic Four #98, May, 1970 entitled "Doomsday on the Moon!"...


....wherein three of the Fantastic Four were behind the scenes, fighting Kree Sentry #9168, while Sue was still back on Earth, recovering from the birth of her son, Franklin Richards!  The "a" was something Neil Armstrong said he had said, but static interfered with it in the transmission to Earth).


Quite a moving scene..

....but, the Fantastic Four had been to the moon before!

Feels Like The First Time


Back in Fantastic Four #13 (April, 1963, by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby), the Fantastic Four completed the mission that originally got them their powers, by getting to the moon...this time, in competition with the Red Ghost and his Super-Apes (Miklho, Peotor and Igor), and while the Fantastic Four had proper shielding this time, the Russians didn't, so they got super-powers on their way to the moon.  Both groups were headed toward the Blue Area of the Moon, which, they discovered had an abandoned city, as well as an Earth-like atmosphere...and one resident...the Watcher!

Watching You


Uatu the Watcher was part of an alien race that watched over beings in the universe, who had a strict noninterference code to not aid the races they watched (due to previous interference by other Watchers, that resulted in an immature race getting nuclear weapons and destroying themselves thanks to the Watchers interference, as told in Tales of Suspense #53, May, 1964).

But, Uatu seemed to like the Fantastic Four, interfering with the Molecule Man (Fantastic Four #20, November, 1963), the wedding of Reed and Sue (Fantastic Four Annual #3, 1965), and trying to hide Earth from planet-eater Galactus (Fantastic Four #48, March, 1966)!  Uatu was even placed on trial for these acts (but was sentenced to continue his job, with less interference in Captain Marvel #37 to #39 in 1975).  The Watcher even had his own back-up series in Tales of Suspense (starting in #49, January, 1964, and running to #58, October, 1964), as well as telling tales of alternate timelines of the Marvel Universe (Earth-616), starting with What If? #1 (February, 1977)...but, perhaps it's best not to open that can of worms just yet...

Love Is A Battlefield


The X-Men ended up on the Blue Area of the Moon, thanks to Professor X's love and head the Shi'ar, and the X-Men battled the Imperial Guard for the life of what they thought was Jean Grey (really, the Phoenix) all in X-Men #137 (September, 1980 by Chris Claremont and John Byrne).  Wolverine even has a brief encounter with the Watcher in his citadel (that does not go well for Wolverine).

The teams fight under the observation of Skrull and Kree agents (the Skrull and Kree are intergalactic races introduced on Earth in the Fantastic Four, and they have been warring for a long time... and the Kree were creators of the Blue City, left in ruins, on the moon, while the Skrulls had created the Blue Area of the Moon, to test the Kree and the Cotati, who created the atmosphere of the area...all a million years ago!).  This moment was also revisited by the Watcher a few times in What If?.

Moving On Up 


The Inhumans even became neighbors to the Watcher for a time...

...after the Earth had become too polluted for them to live their, even in their hidden city of Attilan (also called the Great Refuge).

 (The city of Attilan first appeared in Fantastic Four #47 by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, February, 1966 and the Inhumans as a whole first appeared in Fantastic Four #45, December, 1965, also by Lee and Kirby), with Attilan moving to the moon in Fantastic Four #240 (March, 1982, by John Byrne).

The moon proved a good home for the Inhumans...


...and a reawakening of their Kree genes, as the Inhumans were descendants of humans experimented on by the Kree.

Randac was a leader of the Inhumans, and he discovered the Terrigen Mist, which is what the Inhumans needed to be exposed to in order to gain their powers. 

These powers were often unpredictable....and changed the recipients in unexpected ways. 

Randac's story started in Thor #146 (November, 1967), with more tales of the early Inhumans (pre-Fantastic Four meeting) coming in Thor #147 (in December, 1967, with Sentry #459 being activated by Randac's work as Randac planned to expose all his people to the Terrigan Mist), and the youth of Inhumans leader Black Bolt, getting his time and powers with the mist, in Thor #148 (January, 1968) and Black Bolt, Medusa, Maximus and Triton history until Thor #152 (May, 1968).

The Inhumans knew they could move their home, as they had done it before from the North Atlantic Ocean to the Himalayas, with the help of the Eternals (another ancient super-powered race, hidden on Earth, and created by Jack Kirby), as revealed in What If? #29 and #30 (October and November, 1981), all before Black Bolt met the FF in Fantastic Four #45, and well before the Inhumans first stand alone series in the first ten issues of Amazing Adventures (from August, 1970 to August, 1972)...and the Inhumans getting involved in the Kree-Skrull War in Avengers #95 (January, 1972).

So, with all this, you can see how connected all of Lee and Kirby's creations are, and that the imagination to take us to the moon, also connected to our fantasies of how we see ourselves in the stars and how we are all connected in our dreams!